{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

For over three years, the typical home across the nation experienced month-after-month price increases, but that trend has now shifted. As of October, the median home sales price has fallen below last year's figures for the first time since spring 2023. Simultaneously, the inventory of homes has surged to its highest level since early 2020, pending sales have dipped to their lowest point in over ten years (excluding the early pandemic), and nearly 20% of listings have seen price reductions.

However, the cost of borrowing has risen again. The average rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage has climbed back into the mid-7% range after a brief period of decline. Therefore, while buyers are gaining more negotiating power, the monthly payments continue to strain many households' budgets.

This situation presents a unique opportunity. Sellers are now facing fewer offers and longer times on the market, causing list prices and sale terms to become more negotiable. If you are looking to buy a home this winter, here's what you might have room to negotiate, and how to approach these discussions with your agent and lender.

The significance of a minor price dip

A slight national price decrease of less than 0.5% is far from a market crash, nor does it indicate that values are declining uniformly across the country. Some high-end coastal markets with limited inventory are still experiencing price growth, while certain major metropolitan areas in the South and West have seen declines of several percentage points compared to last year. Your specific local market holds much more significance than national statistics.

What the national figures indicate is a shift in the dynamics favoring buyers. As homes linger on the market and numerous listings vie for a smaller pool of buyers, sellers tend to become more amenable to negotiations. This change can manifest in better pricing, but it often reflects in the overall conditions of the sale.

Price is just one aspect

Many buyers concentrate solely on the sale price. Yet in a high-rate climate, the monthly payment and the amount needed at closing can be even more crucial. A reduction of a few thousand dollars off the price impacts your loan slightly, but reallocating those funds can yield greater benefits for your budget. Common negotiation points in a slower market include:

  • A lower purchase price compared to the listing price
  • A seller concession towards your closing costs
  • Completion of repairs before closing, or a repair credit
  • Funds from the seller to reduce your mortgage interest rate
  • A closing date or move-in timeline aligned with your plans
  • Inclusion of items like appliances or window coverings with the sale

Your agent is knowledgeable about how sellers are responding in your local market and can assist you in prioritizing these requests in your offer. The aim is not to overly burden the seller with requests but to focus on what will matter most for your situation.

Reducing closing costs through seller credits

Typically, closing costs amount to several percent of the loan, in addition to your down payment. For many first-time buyers, gathering the necessary cash poses a significant challenge. Seller credits can alleviate some of these direct expenses, allowing you to bring a lesser amount to the closing table.

Keep in mind that there are restrictions. Different loan programs limit how much a seller can contribute, typically ranging between 3% and 9% of the sale price, depending on the loan type and your down payment. Additionally, a credit may not exceed your actual closing costs. Consulting your lender early on will clarify your specific loan allowances so that your requests align with the regulations.

Understanding rate buydowns

With rates exceeding 7% again, one of the most advantageous offers a seller can make is assistance with your interest rate. There are primarily two types of buydowns.

A permanent buydown involves paying discount points at closing to lower your rate for the entirety of the loan term. Each point amounts to 1% of the loan, and the reduction it provides varies by lender and market conditions. If you intend to keep the loan long-term, a permanent buydown might be beneficial.

A temporary buydown reduces your payments for the initial one or two years. In a typical scenario, the rate drops by two percentage points in the first year and one point in the second year, returning to the full rate afterward. For example, on a $350,000 30-year loan with an interest rate of approximately 7.34%, monthly payments would begin around $1,952 in the first year and about $2,176 in the second year, reverting to the standard rate in year three. Financing this arrangement may cost slightly over $8,000, which a seller may prefer to cover instead of lowering the home price equivalently.

A temporary buydown is not a permanent solution. You should still be comfortable with the full payment once the discount period expires, and lenders often qualify you based on the full rate. Should interest rates decline later, refinancing could be an option, but timing and certainty of such occurrences cannot be guaranteed.

Do not skip inspections to appear competitive

During more competitive markets, many buyers chose to waive inspections or limit requests to secure properties. However, in the current slower market, there's less urgency to forego these protections. A detailed home inspection provides valuable insights into the condition of the roof, HVAC systems, plumbing, electrical wiring, and foundation before you finalize any purchase.

If the inspection reveals issues, your agent can guide you in deciding whether to request repairs, negotiate a price adjustment, or seek a credit. Opting for a credit can simplify matters as it allows you to manage the repairs yourself, though what you choose to ask for will depend on the specific problems and the guidelines of your loan.

Prepare your financing beforehand

Having negotiating leverage is of little use if your financing isn't robust. When a seller is evaluating two offers, they typically prefer the buyer who appears most likely to follow through with the purchase. Before you start your search, obtain a complete preapproval instead of a quick prequalification, have a clear idea of your comfortable monthly payment, and compare loan estimates from several lenders. Also, inquire with each lender about how they would manage a seller credit or buydown to avoid unexpected surprises later.

Key questions to review with your agent

  • How long are homes in this area remaining on the market, and how often do price reductions occur?
  • Would a price reduction, closing cost credit, or rate buydown be the most helpful for my budget?
  • How do the condition and history of this specific property influence what I might request?
  • What contingencies should I include in my offer for my protection?

Final thoughts

A cooling market does not equate to inexpensive buying opportunities, particularly with increasing mortgage rates. However, it does provide diligent buyers greater flexibility to negotiate terms that align with their financial needs. With strong financing, a defined understanding of your priorities, and advice from your agent and lender, you might secure considerably better conditions than buyers could have envisioned just one or two years prior.

Rewritten using AI

Your Next Chapter Starts Here

Find More Than a Home. Find Your Paradise.

Whether you're searching for your first home, your dream waterfront property, or your next investment, McAlister Properties is here to guide you every step of the way.

Personalized Guidance
Local Real Estate Expertise
Dedicated Service